Agile vs. Waterfall vs. Kanban vs. Scrum: What to choose?

Coordinating digital product development is a huge undertaking, especially for large projects. This often means juggling many tasks at once, working with different groups of people, and facing limited resources and strict deadlines.

Without proper coordination, the risks can be significant—missed deadlines, budget overruns, subpar code quality, and unsatisfied stakeholders or users.
The key to mitigating these risks is selecting the proper software development methodology. 

A well-chosen methodology is a blueprint for your team, enabling streamlined processes, clear communication, and consistent expectations among all stakeholders. This alignment is critical for delivering high-quality software on time and within budget.

However, not all methodologies fit every project.

To decide effectively, start by asking yourself two key questions:

What are my team’s primary goals?

Every methodology aims to complete projects, but their unique approaches and benefits cater to different priorities. Identifying your team’s specific goals can help you determine the best fit:

• Speed and adaptability
• Process improvement
• Predictability and structure
• Exploration and innovation

Which methodology will my team consistently follow?

A methodology only works if it’s applied consistently. Without proper adherence, you lose the benefits that make the approach effective:

• Kanban: Without WIP (Work in Progress) limits, Kanban can devolve into just another task management system.
• Waterfall: Failing to keep phases distinct may result in a chaotic process, better suited for Agile methods.

The key is to choose a methodology your team can fully commit to and execute as intended. While you can tailor parts of the framework to fit your needs, deviating too much risks losing the advantages that made the methodology popular in the first place.

Below, we outline a structured framework for initiating projects, evaluating methodologies, and adapting them to meet client needs, based on Reenbit’s experience as a trusted IT services provider.

Initiating a Project

The foundation of every successful project lies in clear communication and comprehensive planning. Here’s how we approach project initiation at Reenbit:

• Client Meetings: The first step involves in-depth discussions to understand key needs, limitations, and expectations. This ensures alignment from the start.
• Requirements Gathering: We document desired outcomes, budget constraints, and the expected timeline to set realistic goals.

The insights gathered here set the stage for selecting an appropriate project methodology.

Factors Influencing Methodology Selection

Every project is unique, and multiple factors influence the choice of methodology. Let’s examine these criteria in detail:

Budget Constraints

The foundation of every successful project lies in clear communication and comprehensive planning. Here’s how we approach project initiation at Reenbit:

• Limited Budget: Agile or Scrum methodologies work best for projects that demand flexibility, cost control, and iterative improvements.
• Stable Budget: Waterfall may be better if the requirements are fixed and clearly defined, ensuring predictable costs.

Team Size

• Small Teams: Lean Development or Scrum allows smaller groups to remain nimble and reduce unnecessary bureaucracy.
• Large Teams: Frameworks like SAFe (Scaled Agile Framework) or Waterfall provide structure and effective task allocation across bigger teams.

Project Stage

• Early-Stage Projects: Lean Startup or Agile is ideal for rapid prototyping and launching an MVP (Minimum Viable Product).
• Development or Release: Scrum offers a phased approach with flexibility for quick adjustments based on user feedback.
• Maintenance and Support: Kanban works well for projects requiring continuous improvement and long-term support.

Complexity

Complex projects involving integrations with APIs or external systems often benefit from Agile or Scrum due to their adaptive nature, allowing for iterative testing and quick fixes.

Changing Requirements

Projects with high variability in requirements should lean towards Agile, while Waterfall suits initiatives with fixed, well-documented needs.

Regulatory Compliance

Waterfall may be necessary to meet strict documentation and compliance standards in heavily regulated industries like healthcare or finance.

Documenting and Validating the Methodology

Once the methodology is selected, it’s crucial to establish a clear project roadmap and validate the approach:

• Development Plan: Create a detailed roadmap outlining the methodology and justifying its selection.
• Performance Evaluation: Regularly assess the methodology’s effectiveness through key performance indicators such as adherence to timelines, budget control, and client satisfaction.

Reviewing and Adjusting the Methodology

Projects evolve, and methodologies should adapt to changing circumstances:

• Reassessment: If the project grows in scale or complexity, reevaluate the current methodology and transition to a more suitable one (e.g., switching from Scrum to Kanban for frequent releases).
• Team Retrospectives: Conduct regular retrospectives to identify bottlenecks and areas for improvement, ensuring the methodology continues to serve the project’s needs effectively.

Top machine learning startups will harness these technologies to optimize resource consumption, reduce waste, and make environmentally conscious decisions, aligning with the global push towards a greener future.

Real-World Applications at Reenbit

At Reenbit, we’ve encountered projects ranging from small MVPs to large-scale enterprise systems. For instance:

• A startup prototype required an Agile approach, enabling quick iterations and delivering an MVP in record time.
• For a healthcare client with strict regulatory requirements, we opted for Waterfall, ensuring full compliance and robust documentation.

Our ability to tailor methodologies to client needs has been key to building long-term partnerships.

Tailoring your development process to each project’s needs ensures efficiency and impact. At Reenbit, we’re dedicated to exceeding client expectations by providing methodologies beyond simply meeting requirements.

Ready to start your next project? Contact us today, and let’s make it a success together.